Blended Learning, Cost of Education, Domestic, Education Quality, Faculty, MOOCs, Private, Public, Recruitment, Required, Student Loans, Universities & Colleges - Written by on Wednesday, October 24, 2012 6:00 - 0 Comments

Princeton’s President Emeritus William G. Bowen Blasts Bloated University Budgets

Rev. John Witherspoon
Photo Credit: dbking via Compfight

Princeton’s president emeritus, William Bown, gave an important set of lectures recently at Stanford University. Bowen sounded the alarm bells that today’s universities suffer from too much waste and a near-fatal “cost disease.” He says the current higher education model is, actually, untenable … with enduring dire cutbacks, tuition hikes ubiquitous and indebted students an ongoing problem. He thinks the nation is approaching a crisis. He asks, interestingly, if technology is the answer?”

“There’s going to have to be a re-engineering of all this,” Bowen remarked Wednesday evening in the first of two talks presented as part of the annual Tanner Lectures on Human Values. The series includes two evening lectures and two discussion sessions. Bowen, president emeritus of Princeton University and of the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, collectively titled his lectures “The ‘Cost Disease’ in Higher Education: Is Technology the Answer?”

The “cost disease” refers to a university’s inability to implement efficiency measures to maintain productivity, like, say, a manufacturing plant might do. Russian teachers, for example, can’t be shifted to the Spanish department. Another difference is the very definition of productivity. It is “maddeningly difficult in the field of education to measure both ‘outputs’ and ‘inputs,’” Bowen said, but there is no question that returns to college students have gone up, both in dollar terms and otherwise. In general, he said, “college is a very good investment.” Also, research productivity has risen hugely, thanks to technological innovation.

But there’s no question that efficiency could be improved. As all citizens of a university campus know, there is duplication, centers that don’t seem to do very much and ingrained institutional resistance to flexibility. Decisions are often compartmentalized in ways that make little sense, Bowen said, implying that business models are being imposed from the outside according to non-university criteria.

Furthermore, at elite universities such as Stanford, there is upward pressure in the form of salary and amenities competition, what Bowen called “the relentless pursuit of reputation” fueled, in part, by college rankings. Top-tier schools increasingly will do whatever it takes to ensure the best educational experience. Though competition does yield results, he said – which is why many American research universities are the best in the world – there is such a thing as “too much competition.”

Does all this add up to a serious problem, a crisis even? Yes, Bowen said, but it does not spell the end of higher education, neither for private schools nor for state universities. The question is how to do more with less. That, he said, is a question of will, not just resources.

With a night to think about the rather grim picture Bowen painted Wednesday evening, a crowd of professors and students gathered Thursday morning to continue the conversation. The respondents were two individuals well versed in the world of educational transformation: Stanford President John Hennessy and Howard Gardner, a professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education.

Gardner’s remarks focused on the importance of the residential education model. If we just let students live in dorms and got rid of the classes, he asked, would it be Plato’s Academy or Lord of the Flies? Admittedly, he said, universities everywhere have “fallen far from the ideals” of residential higher education, but we must figure out ways of preserving its virtues while reducing its cost. “Cut the frills,” he said. “We’re not competing with Marriott.” Hire teachers who want to teach, embrace distance learning, cut support staff and maintain communities with society’s most admirable values.

Engaging Bowen’s question of the previous evening – do we have a cost crisis? – Hennessy said no, we have a cost problem. Where there’s a crisis, he said, is in college completion, which hovers just over 50 percent in public schools. It’s a bit higher for private schools, and plunges to 25 percent in the for-profit sector. And students who don’t complete their education are often those carrying the greatest debt. They owe money and have nothing to show for it. The public university model clearly is untenable, Hennessy said bluntly. “You just have to blow up the system.”

As with the previous evening, the audience appeared captivated and worried, trying to get a handle on the tough choices ahead. Bowen’s nonprofit organization for transformative educational technology is called Ithaka; he knows well that the journey will be long and winding.

“What will the university look like 10 years from now” once all the changes shake down, asked Daphne Koller, one of the commentators for a discussion session today, which will be devoted to online education. Koller, a cofounder of the online education hosting company Coursera, is on leave from her position as a professor of computer science at Stanford. 

“Ten years is not enough,” Bowen replied. “Things will be all over the map. No single paradigm will emerge from all this.”

Via Stanford News

 



Leave a Reply

Comment

Campus Buzz


We welcome Tips & Pitches



Latest WA Original Features








  • Twitter feed loading











APEI40.20  chart-0.17  chart -0.42%
APOL19.01  chart+0.33  chart +1.77%
AAPL460.16  chart-6.43  chart -1.38%
BPI10.74  chart-0.09  chart -0.83%
CAST0.11  chart+0.01  chart +10.00%
CECO4.08  chart-0.02  chart -0.49%
COCO2.40  chart-0.02  chart -0.83%
CPLA32.03  chart-0.41  chart -1.26%
DV30.69  chart+0.36  chart +1.19%
EDMC4.03  chart+0.07  chart +1.77%
ESI18.34  chart+0.04  chart +0.22%
GOOG792.89  chart+5.07  chart +0.64%
LINC6.20  chart+0.06  chart +0.98%
LOPE25.03  chart+0.36  chart +1.46%
PEDH0.45  chart0.00  chart +0.00%
PSO18.51  chart-0.27  chart -1.44%
SABA8.61  chart-0.16  chart -1.82%
SCHL30.87  chart+0.46  chart +1.51%
STRA51.95  chart-1.54  chart -2.88%
WPO414.41  chart+5.35  chart +1.31%
2013-02-15 16:00

Domestic, For-Profit, Gainful Employment, Infographics, Personalized Learning, Private, Public, Required, Universities & Colleges - Jan 31, 2013 6:09 - 0 Comments

Infographic: To Get A Degree Or Not To Get A Degree? Here Is An Answer

More In For-Profit


MOOCs, Required, Technology - Feb 16, 2013 10:04 - 0 Comments

MOOC Monitor: Must Reads This Week

More In Technology


Charter, Cost of Education, Domestic, Education Quality, Friend, Fraud, or Fishy, K-12, Minorities, Regulatory, Required - Feb 7, 2013 12:23 - 0 Comments

Should For-Profit Companies Manage K-12 Schools? A Skeptical Review

More In Friend, Fraud, or Fishy